Xymon Mailing List Archive search

Problems with 'COMPACT'

5 messages in this thread

list Colin Coe · Tue, 29 Jun 2021 06:12:31 +0800 · 
Hi all

I'm trying to use the 'COMPACT' directive for a few custom tests.  My
config looks a it like:
1.1.1.1 a_fim # noconn COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4
NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends
1.1.1.2 b_fim # noconn COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4
NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends
1.1.1.3 c_fim # noconn COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4
NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends

The problem is that the first compacted test (fim_test1) seems to not get
included in the compacting (ie, it shows on the non-green page) and if any
of the compacted tests for any host are non-green, every host with the
compacted test is shown on the non-green page.

Anyone else having this problem or have I configured it wrong?

Thanks
list Colin Coe · Fri, 2 Jul 2021 15:13:08 +0800 · 
Any thoughts on this?  I've had a look at the source but can't see anything
obvious.

Thanks
▸ quoted from Colin Coe

On Tue, 29 Jun 2021 at 06:12, Colin Coe <user-5b250cd7a540@xymon.invalid> wrote:

Hi all

I'm trying to use the 'COMPACT' directive for a few custom tests.  My
config looks a it like:
1.1.1.1 a_fim # noconn COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4
NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends
1.1.1.2 b_fim # noconn COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4
NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends
1.1.1.3 c_fim # noconn COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4
NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends

The problem is that the first compacted test (fim_test1) seems to not get
included in the compacting (ie, it shows on the non-green page) and if any
of the compacted tests for any host are non-green, every host with the
compacted test is shown on the non-green page.

Anyone else having this problem or have I configured it wrong?

Thanks
list Ron Cohen · Tue, 6 Jul 2021 13:43:14 +0100 ·

Your configuration is fine - it is the COMPACT which has issues. Not only it makes the non-green page to look like a Guy Fawkes night, it also adds COMPACT columns from unrelated pages to any page which has  COMPACTed  tests defined.

I haven't seen the the first issue you have specified though - missing 1st test - maybe it relates to the version? I'm on 4.3.28.

Ron

▸ quoted from Colin Coe

On 02/07/2021 08:13, Colin Coe wrote:
Any thoughts on this?  I've had a look at the source but can't see anything obvious.

Thanks

On Tue, 29 Jun 2021 at 06:12, Colin Coe <user-5b250cd7a540@xymon.invalid> wrote:
Hi all
I'm trying to use the 'COMPACT' directive for a few custom tests.  My config looks a it like:
1.1.1.1 a_fim # noconn COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4 NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends
1.1.1.2 b_fim # noconn COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4 NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends
1.1.1.3 c_fim # noconn COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4 NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends

The problem is that the first compacted test (fim_test1) seems to not get included in the compacting (ie, it shows on the non-green page) and if any of the compacted tests for any host are non-green, every host with the compacted test is shown on the non-green page.

Anyone else having this problem or have I configured it wrong?

Thanks



Xymon@xymon.com
list Colin Coe · Wed, 7 Jul 2021 06:21:08 +0800 · 
Hi Ron

Thanks for the response, I'm glad its not just me :)

I'm running v4.3.30.

My comment about the first test: the first test (alphabetically, so in my
example above "fim_test1") is not actually compacted.  It displays as an
individual test on the nongreen or red page, and is not found in the 'fim'
group when I click on that test.

Just looking on the SF site and can't see how to log a bug for this.  Any
suggestions?

Thanks
▸ quoted from Ron Cohen

On Tue, 6 Jul 2021 at 20:43, Ron Cohen <user-f26e06d1e992@xymon.invalid> wrote:

Your configuration is fine - it is the COMPACT which has issues. Not only
it makes the non-green page to look like a Guy Fawkes night, it also adds
COMPACT columns from unrelated pages to any page which has  COMPACTed
tests defined.

I haven't seen the the first issue you have specified though - missing 1st
test - maybe it relates to the version? I'm on 4.3.28.

Ron


On 02/07/2021 08:13, Colin Coe wrote:

Any thoughts on this?  I've had a look at the source but can't see
anything obvious.

Thanks

On Tue, 29 Jun 2021 at 06:12, Colin Coe <user-5b250cd7a540@xymon.invalid> wrote:

Hi all

I'm trying to use the 'COMPACT' directive for a few custom tests.  My
config looks a it like:
1.1.1.1 a_fim # noconn
COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4
NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends
1.1.1.2 b_fim # noconn
COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4
NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends
1.1.1.3 c_fim # noconn
COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4
NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends

The problem is that the first compacted test (fim_test1) seems to not get
included in the compacting (ie, it shows on the non-green page) and if any
of the compacted tests for any host are non-green, every host with the
compacted test is shown on the non-green page.

Anyone else having this problem or have I configured it wrong?

Thanks


Xymon mailing user-d459c9d661b6@xymon.invalid
list Tom Schmidt · Tue, 6 Jul 2021 16:29:54 -0600 · 
I attempted to use COMPACT once to try to combine ftp and ftps tests into a
single column.  However, when I did that, I then only received the ftp
status page and graph instead of it "merging" the two columns data into one
status report as I had hoped.

I know this is not the same issue that you are reporting, but I do not
think the COMPACT function works as intended.

Tom
▸ quoted from Colin Coe

On Tue, Jul 6, 2021 at 4:21 PM Colin Coe <user-5b250cd7a540@xymon.invalid> wrote:

Hi Ron

Thanks for the response, I'm glad its not just me :)

I'm running v4.3.30.

My comment about the first test: the first test (alphabetically, so in my
example above "fim_test1") is not actually compacted.  It displays as an
individual test on the nongreen or red page, and is not found in the 'fim'
group when I click on that test.

Just looking on the SF site and can't see how to log a bug for this.  Any
suggestions?

Thanks

On Tue, 6 Jul 2021 at 20:43, Ron Cohen <user-f26e06d1e992@xymon.invalid> wrote:

Your configuration is fine - it is the COMPACT which has issues. Not only
it makes the non-green page to look like a Guy Fawkes night, it also adds
COMPACT columns from unrelated pages to any page which has  COMPACTed
tests defined.

I haven't seen the the first issue you have specified though - missing
1st test - maybe it relates to the version? I'm on 4.3.28.

Ron


On 02/07/2021 08:13, Colin Coe wrote:

Any thoughts on this?  I've had a look at the source but can't see
anything obvious.

Thanks

On Tue, 29 Jun 2021 at 06:12, Colin Coe <user-5b250cd7a540@xymon.invalid> wrote:

Hi all

I'm trying to use the 'COMPACT' directive for a few custom tests.  My
config looks a it like:
1.1.1.1 a_fim # noconn
COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4
NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends
1.1.1.2 b_fim # noconn
COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4
NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends
1.1.1.3 c_fim # noconn
COMPACT:fim=fim_test1|fim_test2|fim_test3|fim_test4
NOCOLUMNS:conn,info,trends

The problem is that the first compacted test (fim_test1) seems to not
get included in the compacting (ie, it shows on the non-green page) and if
any of the compacted tests for any host are non-green, every host with the
compacted test is shown on the non-green page.

Anyone else having this problem or have I configured it wrong?

Thanks


Xymon mailing user-d459c9d661b6@xymon.invalid