Xymon Mailing List Archive search

Issues/confusion with 4.3.3

4 messages in this thread

list James B. Huber · Tue, 17 May 2011 09:35:20 -0400 ·
Hi folks,
  Have been using BigBrother, then Hobbit, now Xymon for many years. I
recently built a new machine and did a clean install/build of xymon
4.3.3 and am having some issues/confusion I hope the list can help me
with.

  My first major issue is with the "clamd" service check, this worked
fine under Fedora-13 and Xymon-4.2.3, however (new O/S is RHEL 6.0
Workstation) with Xymon 4.3.3 all it does is fail saying:
"Service unavailable (Connection refused)"....

I can telnet to port 3310, type "PING" and it comes back with "PONG"
which is what the protocols.cfg says...I have tried turning off
"banner", no help....I am doubtless missing something simple...

FYI, all the other service check I use work fine (IE: DNS, IMAP, NTP,
SMTP)....WHat am I missing ?

Regards, and TIA,
Jim
--
Attachments (1)
list Phil Crooker · Wed, 18 May 2011 09:45:54 +1000 ·
It is odd. The other services you mention working, these are on the same
host as the clamd? If not, try one just to see that something works. 

When you say you can telnet to the clamd port, is that from the xymon
server as the xymon (or whichever) user? Have you tried a simple
connection - no send/expect?

On 5/17/2011 at 11:35 PM, in message
<1305639320.4811.5.camel at GNSD830-01>,
quoted from James B. Huber
"James B. Huber" <user-10a86bf5a562@xymon.invalid> wrote: 
Hi folks,
  Have been using BigBrother, then Hobbit, now Xymon for many years.
I
recently built a new machine and did a clean install/build of xymon
4.3.3 and am having some issues/confusion I hope the list can help
me
with.

  My first major issue is with the "clamd" service check, this
worked
fine under Fedora-13 and Xymon-4.2.3, however (new O/S is RHEL 6.0
Workstation) with Xymon 4.3.3 all it does is fail saying:
"Service unavailable (Connection refused)"....

I can telnet to port 3310, type "PING" and it comes back with "PONG"
which is what the protocols.cfg says...I have tried turning off
"banner", no help....I am doubtless missing something simple...

FYI, all the other service check I use work fine (IE: DNS, IMAP,
NTP,
SMTP)....WHat am I missing ?

Regards, and TIA,
Jim
--
list James B. Huber · Tue, 17 May 2011 21:23:03 -0400 ·
Hi Phil,
  Yes the services that are working are on the same server, it is the
xymon server, and indeed as the xymon user I can telnet to the
machines's IP on the port of clamd and it works just fine...

Doesn't make any sense to me, I go back to 4.2.3 and it works fine. Got
to be something simple I am overlooking or the clamd service check in
xymon isn't actually going to the IP of the machine...but I've got no
clue how to debug that and see what it thinks it is trying to open the
connection to.

Jim
quoted from Phil Crooker
--

On Wed, 2011-05-18 at 09:45 +1000, Phil Crooker wrote:
It is odd. The other services you mention working, these are on the same
host as the clamd? If not, try one just to see that something works. 

When you say you can telnet to the clamd port, is that from the xymon
server as the xymon (or whichever) user? Have you tried a simple
connection - no send/expect?

On 5/17/2011 at 11:35 PM, in message
<1305639320.4811.5.camel at GNSD830-01>,
"James B. Huber" <user-10a86bf5a562@xymon.invalid> wrote: 
Hi folks,
  Have been using BigBrother, then Hobbit, now Xymon for many years.
I
recently built a new machine and did a clean install/build of xymon
4.3.3 and am having some issues/confusion I hope the list can help
me
with.

  My first major issue is with the "clamd" service check, this
worked
fine under Fedora-13 and Xymon-4.2.3, however (new O/S is RHEL 6.0
Workstation) with Xymon 4.3.3 all it does is fail saying:
"Service unavailable (Connection refused)"....

I can telnet to port 3310, type "PING" and it comes back with "PONG"
which is what the protocols.cfg says...I have tried turning off
"banner", no help....I am doubtless missing something simple...

FYI, all the other service check I use work fine (IE: DNS, IMAP,
NTP,
SMTP)....WHat am I missing ?

Regards, and TIA,
Jim
--
list Phil Crooker · Wed, 18 May 2011 12:11:19 +1000 ·
On 5/18/2011 at 11:23 AM, in message
<user-cedd86e33ea3@xymon.invalid>, "James B. Huber"
quoted from James B. Huber
<user-10a86bf5a562@xymon.invalid> wrote: 
Hi Phil,
  Yes the services that are working are on the same server, it is
the
xymon server, and indeed as the xymon user I can telnet to the
machines's IP on the port of clamd and it works just fine...

Doesn't make any sense to me, I go back to 4.2.3 and it works fine.
Got
to be something simple I am overlooking or the clamd service check
in
xymon isn't actually going to the IP of the machine...but I've got
no
clue how to debug that and see what it thinks it is trying to open
the
connection to.

Jim
Hi Jim,

I'm pretty new to xymon so don't know the guts yet... But, just in
general troubleshooting mode - try just a connection only test:

[clamd]
      port 3310

See if that works. Have you tried using the --debug option for
xymonnet? It does give quite a bit of info.

cheers.
quoted from Phil Crooker

--

On Wed, 2011-05-18 at 09:45 +1000, Phil Crooker wrote:
It is odd. The other services you mention working, these are on the
same
host as the clamd? If not, try one just to see that something works.
When you say you can telnet to the clamd port, is that from the
xymon
server as the xymon (or whichever) user? Have you tried a simple
connection - no send/expect?

On 5/17/2011 at 11:35 PM, in message
<1305639320.4811.5.camel at GNSD830-01>,
"James B. Huber" <user-10a86bf5a562@xymon.invalid> wrote: 
Hi folks,
  Have been using BigBrother, then Hobbit, now Xymon for many
years.
I
recently built a new machine and did a clean install/build of
xymon
4.3.3 and am having some issues/confusion I hope the list can
help
me
with.

  My first major issue is with the "clamd" service check, this
worked
fine under Fedora-13 and Xymon-4.2.3, however (new O/S is RHEL
6.0
Workstation) with Xymon 4.3.3 all it does is fail saying:
"Service unavailable (Connection refused)"....

I can telnet to port 3310, type "PING" and it comes back with
"PONG"
which is what the protocols.cfg says...I have tried turning off
"banner", no help....I am doubtless missing something simple...

FYI, all the other service check I use work fine (IE: DNS, IMAP,
NTP,
SMTP)....WHat am I missing ?

Regards, and TIA,
Jim
--