Xymon Mailing List Archive search

Feedback on using AI/LLMs for Xymon development and reviews

list Roland Rosenfeld
Thu, 10 Sep 2026 21:11:46 +0200
Message-Id: <user-6a95f7aba292@xymon.invalid>

Hi Bruno!

On Do, 10 Sep 2026, Bruno Manzoni via Xymon wrote:
Let me know what you think!
Maybe I'm too old and pessimistic, but I don't like the new workflow,
where IA generates tons of code and comments, that I have to read and
review.  I understand that this may be the future, but the frequency
that it generates code doesn't match my performance of code review.

So I'm completely ambivalent: On the one side I'm very happy, that
xymon is alive and updated, on the other side I have not much fun
reviewing the AI generated stuff.

Maybe that will change at some point in time, but at the moment I
personally didn't reach this point.

Maybe it's also a problem, that I'm not a C developer.  I can read and
understand C (and write small fixes), but this usually takes much
time.  So it looks that the AI outclasses me, which doesn't feel good.

That said, the project needs more C developers that are able to review
the AI generated stuff...

Except this, I still ask myself what all this AI generated code means
to the LICENSE/Copyright of the project.
COPYING file is GPL-2, most source files are Copyright Henrik Storner
<user-e180c691dbbd@xymon.invalid>, but what about the code generated by AI?  At
least the tests reference GPL-2+, but no copyright or author is
mentioned.  So can this really be GPL-2+ without a copyright owner?

I'm not sure about all this...

Greetings
Roland